Why don’t Hindus promote their Dharma? – Maria Wirth

Maria Wirth is a German author and commentator who studied psychology at Hamburg University. She has lived in Uttarakhand for many decades and is best known for her blog and recent book ‘Thank you India : A German Woman’s Journey to the Wisdom of Yoga’.

The insights of the Vedic Rishis need not be pushed; they only need to be known. They result in a very beneficial mindset, definitely far more beneficial than the divisive, narrow mindset of the newcomer religions. Knowing that God is within gives inner strength, and knowing that God is also in others, including in animals and nature, makes people kind. This broad mindset needs to dominate in the world, and it is Hindus who can lead the way.

Anchors at Indian TV channels are generally intelligent and capable. However, when the topic involves religion, they often lack common sense or courage.

Recently, Rishab Gulati said on NewsX that he wants to explore how to bring the Indian Muslims, who had been brainwashed into hard Wahhabi Islam, back to a softer Sufi version. Rishab surely would know that all versions of Islam are based on the Quran and he would also know that the stark division between believers, who are considered good, and unbelievers, who are considered bad, is fixed in this foundational text itself.

So why would he not rather explore how Muslims could be brought back to their ancient, benevolent Hindu Dharma ? It would make far more sense. Why would he want a big part of Indians to continue to believe blindly, albeit in a softer version, what the invaders violently enforced several centuries ago ? Why is he so diffident about his own tradition which has contributed maximum knowledge to science and human civilization in general ?

The reason may be that over the last thousand years, it was very dangerous to stand up for Hindu Dharma. So people tried to be diplomatic, made compromises, and did not mention and certainly not praise their Dharma, even if they greatly valued it. This attitude seems to have got deeply ingrained and is present even in today’s generation. The English education system also did its bit to cement this attitude and even made it worse, as it portrayed the indigenous tradition contrary to facts as inferior. Not wanting to be ‘controversial’ is uppermost in the mind of many Hindus, when they deal with converts. They rather indulge them, than ask probing questions.

This attitude is, however, in our times not helpful but dangerous. We have a window now, where we can be truthful and talk about the great advantage that Hindu Dharma has over Christianity and Islam. If we don’t use it, it may close again and then probably for a long time.

Most Hindus know, and if some still don’t know, it is urgent that they come to know, that both Christianity and Islam consider it as their divine duty to make their religion dominate the whole globe. Only then their God/Allah will be happy and start the Judgement Day proceedings, when the good believers are allowed to enter Heaven. It has however not yet been clarified whether the Christian or Muslim believers have this privilege, as only one ‘true religion’ can naturally be true. For Hindus, of course, it will be Hell, both agree on this.

Can any sane person believe that the Creator of this unimaginably vast Universe will punish the majority of human beings eternally in hellfire because they did not accept that the truth about how we should live, was revealed only recently and only to one particular person on this earth which is already some billion years old ?

There are other points which are not flattering for those two religions : Christianity and Islam are not based on reason, intuition or experience, but only on blind belief. One can never know if Jesus is really the son of God who was sent to earth to save us from the original sin and who declared that the way to the father goes only through him.

Or we can never know if Allah really communicated via Gabriel with Prophet Mohammed and declared that he is the last prophet and all must follow what Mohammed said.

These two religions make blind, unverifiable belief, which is not a healthy attitude, look like a virtue : if you believe blindly what the padres or the mullahs tell you, you will be rewarded with eternal Heaven after Judgement Day, is promised. It is an effective method to keep people subdued on earth, waiting for Heaven. And common people suspected this already in the dark ages. In Germany, we have an old saying that the Pope makes people stupid and the King makes them poor.

Unfortunately, only members of Christianity and Islam go all out to spread their religion with full zest and especially in the case of Christianity, with lots of money and a detailed strategy. Pious members of both religions do not hesitate to claim that their religion alone is true and all others are wrong and will not be accepted by the ‘true God’. They have nothing to support their claim, except that the founder of their religion allegedly said so. This claim of eternal damnation is meant to frighten people to fall in line. On the other hand, it makes them arrogant, believing ‘We are the chosen ones. We believe the right thing. Earth and Heaven belong to us. All others are damned for eternity’.

Believing their clergy, they are on a mission to eradicate all other faiths. And how successful they have been ! All ancient cultures were eradicated, except for the Indian culture.

In India, those two religions have encountered the greatest resistance. Indian culture still stands but greatly diminished. Yet, neither Christianity nor Islam has conceded defeat. On the contrary, they push harder than ever now by demonizing Hindus to an unbelievable degree. Do they want the world to believe a false narrative that an ‘uprising of the oppressed Muslims against the demonic Hindus’ is justified and must be supported ?

There is, however, one great power on the side of Hindus. It is Truth, on the relative level – Truth is that Muslims are not oppressed in India, on the contrary – and on the absolute, spiritual level – Truth is one.

Hindu Dharma is the best option for humanity. Nobody is forced to believe anything that does not make sense or cannot be experienced. Hindu Dharma is not a fixed, unverifiable belief system. It is based on reason, intuition and experience. Its claims make sense and can be verified, like the most basic claim that the essence in all is one and the same – Sat-Chit-Ananda – blissful awareness behind the names and forms.

But for people to know this, they need to be told, including those whose forefathers have converted and who have been brainwashed into blind belief. If they knew and reflect on those insights, they might see that indeed Hindu Dharma is the best option. Therefore, it would be so much better if Hindus went all out and informed others of the value of Hindu Dharma.

Compare the Indian reluctance to project its wisdom with China. China has only a few Sages but makes full use of them. It has already established 15 years ago, hundreds of Confucius institutes all over the world which are affiliated to colleges and universities. They teach Chinese language and promote Chinese culture to the Western world.

India is the cradle of civilization. It has so much knowledge, and millions of texts are not even translated into English. It has Sanskrut, the language which helps develop the brain, apart from being a perfect language; it has documentation of a number of great Sages reaching back thousands of years, it has the deepest philosophy still expressed in a vibrant religion; a huge body of literature, amazing art, dance, music, sculpture, architecture, Yoga, Ayurveda, delicious cuisine, incredible temples and yet Indians do little to propagate those treasures. “We are not like them”, many Hindus say, “We don’t advertise our religion and push them into accepting it, like the others”.

The insights of the Vedic Rishis need not be pushed; they only need to be known. They result in a very beneficial mindset, definitely far more beneficial than the divisive, narrow mindset of the newcomer religions. Knowing that God is within gives inner strength, and knowing that God is also in others, including in animals and nature, makes people kind. This broad mindset needs to dominate the world, and it is Hindus who can lead the way.

Bad people would still exist; they are there in every age, but normal, good people would not be indoctrinated en-masse by their clergy into despising and even killing ‘unbelievers’ because they worship the Supreme Intelligence by other names. Looking at Muslims and Christian countries, such an attitude also does not seem to make for a happy society.

Meanwhile, especially in the West, many Christians and Muslims lost faith and say it openly. I am one of them and sometimes Hindus tell me : “It’s good that you write. You are an insider, you can do it. We can’t.” My reply is : “YOU need to speak up. Don’t wait for ex-Christians or ex-Muslims. Most of us, who lost faith, don’t bother about religion any longer. But YOU have been suffering for centuries, with millions killed, and the danger is real that it may happen again. If someone is fully authorised to talk about those doctrines, and the harmful mindset they produce, it is YOU, Indian Hindus. In fact, you owe it to those millions who were massacred for being Hindus”.

Fortunately, in recent years more Hindus speak up. Maybe soon a mainstream channel will have the courage to debate frankly what Muslims & Christians are taught about Hindu kafirs and heathens, and maybe more Christians & Muslims in India, who have lost faith in their religion, have the courage to say it openly. It surely would be a relief for them. Living a lie by pretending to be believers is painful. Hindus can help by being truthful, even if it means being ‘controversial’.

– Ms. Maria Wirth